Evaluation of new technologies to support asset management of metro systems

Since 1930, London Underground Limited (LUL) has performed visual inspections to understand the condition of the physical assets such as tunnels, bridges and structures. The major problem with this kind of inspection is the lack in quality of the data, as it depends on the ability of the inspector to assess and interpret the condition of the asset both accurately and with repeatability. In addition, data collection is time-consuming and, therefore, costly when the whole of the metro network needs to be regularly inspected and there are limited periods when access is available. The problems associated with access to the infrastructure have increased significantly with the implementation of the night tube and will increase further as the night tube is extended over the next 5 to 10 years. To determine the condition of metro assets and to predict the need for intervention, monitoring the changes in the assets’ condition is key to any further evaluation and maintenance planning. This thesis presents the outcomes of using new technologies such as Thermography, Kinematic and Static Laser Scanning, Close-Range Photogrammetry and Total Station to measure defects, such as water seepage, mortar loss in joints, lining face loss (in brick tunnels), cracks, corrosion, voids, cavities and spalls. Each technique is explored through three case studies that evaluate the performance and limitation in the determination of the asset condition. The first case study was performed to compare and contrast the use of Euroconsult’s high definition laser survey against a Principal Inspection Report to determine the level of consistency in predicting the asset condition. During this case study, reports from laser surveys and principal inspections of brick tunnels and covered ways were compared. This analysis showed that a direct comparison between the two inspections is not appropriate because the laser inspection does not capture all the defects mentioned in the Engineering Standard S1060. It also showed that to close the gap between the laser survey and visual inspection, laser surveys would have to be performed every year in brick tunnels and then compare any changes in asset condition with that from the previous scan. The second case study was performed using Infrared Thermography (IRT) to identify water seepage in the brick tunnels as well as test the system in a configuration that would allow the survey to be done from an engineering train. A set of calibration tests were performed in the lab and later the technique was trialled on an engineering train. The results showed that it is possible to measure the level of moisture on specific parts of the lining and that the comparison of surveys performed at different times can allow asset managers to react before a seepage is established, potentially reducing the risk of system disruption caused by water ingress in tunnels. The data also revealed that this technique could be used for other purposes, such as examining the condition of other assets such as brackets, cable supports and broken light bulbs. The third case study was performed using a Terrestrial Laser Scanner, Close-Range Photogrammetry and Total Station Survey to identify defects in structures. In order to test these technologies, a wing wall, located on the north-east wing of the HC3 underbridge at Ladbroke Grove Station, was chosen. This case study demonstrated that LUL can easily implement this type of technology to inspect rapidly their buildings and structures, being able to identify defects and monitor their assets for translation, rotation and changes in shape during changes in loading or the decay of the structure (insidious decline) and the construction of nearby assets. In this research, a large volume of data was captured, and further work is needed in order to manage the data using ‘big data’ concepts. Although it may not be possible to fully understand the insidious decline of an asset, the use of these techniques allows us to better understand how a civil asset behaves, potentially reducing the amount of reactive maintenance to a minimum, consequently reducing service costs and falls in revenue due to disruptions in the system. To successfully analyse the data from new technologies a combination of skills is required and different or retrained personal will be needed